If your client has wrist pain or Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, this article instructs you what to look for when advising them about purchasing a better-fit mouse. If you have any questions about specific mice or if you have any mouse that you want reviewed please let me know!
I do a lot of office ergonomic assessments, consulting, and training]\\\. Clients frequently ask me about what the best mouse available on the market is.
They're usually not happy after I tell them that 'it depends'. But it really does depend on many factors!
Today’s review is based on an article that examines mouse type and the reduction of wrist pain risks. Overtime, under very specific scenarios wrist pain can develop into an extreme and painful condition, known as Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS).
Mice features can contribute to CTS symptoms by increasing the following ergonomic risks:
This is where ‘alternative’ mice come into play. Usually, manufacturers boast that their products can reduce or prevent CTS risk. There is, however, very limited supporting evidence!
These types of mice either promote a more neutral wrist and forearm position or prevent external pressure over the palmar wrist region.
The authors of this study chose to examine the effectiveness of ‘ergonomically’ designed mice and mouse pads in those with CTS. An ergonomically designed vertical mouse (to promote a more neutral forearm position), a gel mouse pad (to promote a more neutral wrist position), a gliding palm support (to promote a more neutral wrist position while decreasing external pressure of the carpal tunnel) and a standard mouse (for comparison reasons) were used.
The results of this study indicate that the already elevated wrist pressure in patients with CTS is further increased when using a conventional/traditional computer mouse.
None of the above evaluated ergonomic devices (that are commonly recommended for CTS) resulted in a reduction in wrist pressure.
Further, it is well established that progressive wrist extension (upwards wrist movement) and ulnar deviation (side to side wrist movement) increases wrist pressure in healthy participations and patients with CTS.
All devices in this study could not entirely prevent an increase in wrist extension and ulnar deviation. The vertical mouse limited the amount of ulnar deviation and the addition of ergonomic wrist pads reduced wrist extension compared to a standard mouse.
When you recommend alternative mice to a client, do you typically have a couple of 'favourite'? If so, what are they?
Leave a comment below and let me know what your favourite mouse to recommend is!